From: info@edgwarecommunity.org <info@edgwarecommunity.org>
Sent: 30 January 2025 5:31 PM
To: Members of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Cc: leader’s office
leader of the opposition
all the councillors in Barnet (in a separate email)
Subject: Why Site 28 (Edgware Underground & Bus Stations) Must Be Removed from the Local Plan
Dear Members of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee,
Ahead of today’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting, we would like to reiterate why the selection of Site 28 is wholly irrational. Over 420 residents have already written to the Committee, urging the removal of Site 28 from the Local Plan, and over 6,000 objections have been submitted to the Ballymore planning application—two-thirds of which relate to Site 28.
We respectfully request that the members of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee move an amendment to remove Site 28 from the Local Plan and update any related policies accordingly.
Extensive research has been conducted on Site 28, which has been proposed by TfL and accepted by Barnet Council as suitable for housing. The Draft Local Plan allocates 2,316 homes to Site 28 in Edgware, which encompasses operational transport infrastructure, a protected nature reserve, and one of London’s busiest bus stations and garages. This unprecedented decision designates the entire 8.17 hectares of land — including live underground stations, operational tracks, a bus station, a bus garage and a nature reserve — as suitable for the highest-density residential development. (Source EXAM 36 – LBB Note – Housing Numbers: 2,316 units is derived from 8.17 hectares land x highest Central density of 405 housing units/hectare x 70% residential to commercial ratio)

1) Why allocating 839 homes on the TfL land of Edgware tube station, tracks and sidings is wrong
The area of the Edgware Tube Station and track area is 2.96 hectares. Barnet Council has decided that the entire live operational Northern Line station and track area can be used to build 839 homes (i.e., 2.96 x 405 u/ha x 70%). This surely is UNSOUND!
This is contrary to the Edgware SPD (Section 5.20), which states:
“London Underground infrastructure, comprising tracks and sidings, is expected to remain available over the long term for operational purposes.”
In Section 7.9, under Public Transport Accessibility, Legibility, and Capacity, it states that the development must:
- Protect line capacity to support growth in Edgware and along this branch of the Northern Line, including depot space and rail sidings.
- Support bus reliability and access by safeguarding space for bus operations/standing and improving the public realm of the bus station itself.
This vital TfL infrastructure land should not be allocated for the highest-density homes.
2) Why demolishing the Bus Station and replace it with a few bus stops will cause congestion on Station Road
By using the entire 2.67 hectares of the Bus Station land for high-density housing, Barnet Council has implied that 757 homes (2.67 hectares x 405 u/ha x 70%) can be built on the operational TfL Bus Station and Garage land.
To develop this land, the existing 68-seater enclosed bus station would be relocated to the London Underground forecourt on Station Road, as illustrated by the Ballymore Plan.
Current Bus Station Facilities: (Source:TfL)
“The existing bus station includes four bus stops and six bus stands next to an island bus station; the island itself is approximately 90 metres long and 7 metres wide. It is enclosed space, providing all-year-round weather protection for passengers.”

TfL’s Concerns Over Relocation: (Source:TfL)
“The proposed relocation of all bus stops into the LU station forecourt will require a complete redesign of the area and must ensure sufficient space for buses and passengers without impacting safety or efficiency.”
Growth Projections by TfL: (Source: TfL Spatial Planning team forecasts in their Pre Application advice)
- 50% increase in bus and passenger capacity at the bus station.
- 40% increase in bus garages and off-highway stands.
Replacing the bus station with stops on Station Road fails to support this projected growth and will cause congestion.

This is contrary to the Edgware SPD, which states that development must:
“Ensure that public transport uses (bus garage; bus station and stand; rail station, sidings, and depot) remain viable and can continue or grow without unreasonable restrictions being placed on them.”
Reducing the 68-seater, six-stand, four-stop bus station to a few scattered bus stops severely restricts bus operations and will lead to major congestion on Station Road.
3) Edgware bus garage land is unsuitable for development due to fire risk
To use the bus garage land for development, Ballymore proposes relocating the 190-bus garage underground, beneath thousands of high-rise homes.
- The bus garage must be fully electric.
- The GLA Stage 1 Report states the importance of:
“Ensuring the bus garage will be delivered fully electric, in both the interim and permanent scheme.” - TfL mandates:
“Bus stands should have opportunity electric charging for the fully electric fleet expected by 2030.”
Lack of Capacity to Accommodate Future Growth of 50%: (Source: TfL Pre-Application Advice)
- The current bus garage accommodates 190 buses and 700 employees (bus drivers, engineers, maintenance, and administrative staff).
- TfL forecasts an increase to 228 buses, yet Ballymore’s underground plan only provides space for 200 buses.
The London Fire Brigade raised serious concerns about the proposal to put . In 2023, they deemed the proposed underground bus garage beneath 25 tower blocks as “not viable.” By 2024, the LFB had further warned that the proposed underground electric bus garage, designed to accommodate 200 buses beneath high-rise flats, poses substantial fire safety risks, including structural collapse and the potential for toxic vapor explosions.
These alarming issues have been widely reported by prominent outlets such as the International Fire and Safety Journal, Fire Protection Association, The Daily Telegraph, The Sun, BBC and the Evening Standard.
Relocating the bus garage underground creates fire safety risks and restricts future growth, contradicting the Edgware SPD:
“Ensure that public transport uses (bus garage; bus station and stand; rail station, sidings, and depot) remain viable and can continue or grow without unreasonable restrictions being placed on them.”
4) Deans Brook Nature Reserve and water course land is unsuitable for development of 720 homes
The fourth component of Site 28 is the Deans Brook Nature Reserve, a protected habitat for species such as bats and slow worms. The public is excluded from this area, meaning it cannot reasonably be considered a development site.
Barnet Council has allocated 720 homes (2.54 hectares x 405 u/ha x 70%) on this nature reserve—a complete disregard for protected wildlife.
Even the Site 28 description in the Local Plan states:
“Proposals should preserve the area of Borough Importance for Nature Conservation, which covers the southeastern part of the site, including the areas around Deans Brook.”
Ballymore’s plan would destroy 34% of the nature reserve woodland, endangering bat and slow worm habitats.
—————————————————————————————
Despite repeated inquiries to TfL and Barnet Council, no satisfactory rationale has been provided for selecting this site. Despite requesting information, we have seen nothing to suggest that there has been an assessment of the impact of Site 28 selection on transport infrastructure and the environment. The papers put before the council were prepared in 2019, and since then there has a groundswell of local opposition. What have councillors done to ensure that the environment, transport infrastructure and local concerns have been carefully assessed?
We request that Site 28 be removed from the Local Plan and that all relevant policies (MM 109, pages 484-488) be updated accordingly.
We look forward to your response and confirmation of whether this amendment will be moved.
Yours sincerely,
Edgware Community Association
