Edgware Community Association and Save Our Edgware's objection submission as a consultee
Summary of Objections by ECA:
- Housing Density & Urban Design: Proposal includes 25 high-rise buildings (up to 29 storeys), creating one of the densest developments in the UK, with 137,974 people/km²—1,860% higher than Edgware’s norm
- Fire Safety Risks: The London Fire Brigade has flagged the proposed underground electric bus garage for 200 buses beneath high-rise flats as a significant fire hazard due to lithium battery risks (Source BBC and The Standard).

- Loss of Bus Station: The removal of the 68-seater, 20+ routes covered bus station with a few bus stops on Station Road means more congestion and longer distances (100–150m) to reach the Underground Station, disproportionately impacting elderly and disabled individuals

- 48% Reduction of A1 Retail Space: Demolition of Broadwalk Shopping Centre will cut retail space (excluding food and food superstore) by 48%, undermining Edgware’s economic viability as a town centre
- Loss of 34% of Wildlife Habitat in Deans Brook: 34% of the Deans Brook Nature Reserve will be destroyed, violating Barnet’s DM04 policy and harming habitats for bats and slow worms.
- 70% Parking Reduction & Accessibility Issues: Public parking is reduced by over 70% (from 1,235 to 292 spaces), including inadequate provision for Blue Badge holders (up to 400m from residences), far exceeding the 50m standard
- 85% Shortfall of Green Spaces: Public and green space shortfalls exceed 85%, providing only 3.25 hectares against the required 21.8 hectares for 10,900 residents

- Overshadowing Impact: Over 50% of windows in 176 neighbouring properties will receive inadequate daylight, with 21% of amenity areas in shadow for at least half the year. Properties on Station Road, Premier Place, Brook Avenue, and Fairfield Crescent will experience severe sunlight loss, harming residents’ quality of life.

- Inadequate Nursery, School and Healthcare Infrastructure: No nursery provision for 504 expected children, insufficient primary and secondary school capacity, and inadequate healthcare plans for the full 10,900 population
- Heritage at Risk: The high-rise design harms the townscape, particularly heritage assets like St. Margaret’s Church and the Railway Hotel as well as the Watling Estate Conservation Area and Canons Park Estate Conservation Area, contradicting NPPF and London Plan policies, according to Historic England, LB Barnet heritage and LB Harrow.
- Community Disruption: A 12-year construction period risks prolonged traffic, noise, and economic disruption, harming local businesses and residents
- Unsound Site 28 Allocation of 2,316 High-Density Homes to TfL Edgware Station Site and Nature Hub in the Local Plan: This unprecedented decision designates live underground stations, operational tracks, a bus station, and a bus garage as suitable for the highest-density residential development. Site 28 accounts for two-thirds of Ballymore’s Broadwalk Development application for 3,365 homes, which has already drawn a record breaking 6,000+ objections from residents and significant criticism from key stakeholders, including the London Fire Brigade (LFB) and the Environment Agency.

SOE objection part 1 – read more
All the representations made by the Edgware Community Association are considered as Save Our Edgware’s representations.
