Request to Remove Site 28 : Unsound allocation of 2,316 homes on TfL Land in Barnet’s Local Plan
On January 30th, the Overview and Scrutiny Committee* will review Barnet’s Local Plan before it moves to Cabinet.
Among its proposals is Site 28, which allocates 2,316 homes by applying the London Plan’s highest density threshold of 405 homes per hectare for a central location. This allocation covers the entire operational TfL land, including an underground station, bus station, bus garage, and a protected nature reserve in Edgware.
This proposal is unprecedented, unsuitable, and undeliverable, posing a threat to vital infrastructure and our local environment. It stands out as unparalleled among the UK’s 35,000 brownfield sites.
Site 28 accounts for two-thirds of Ballymore’s Broadwalk Development application for 3,365 homes, which has already drawn a record breaking 6,000+ objections from residents and criticism from the London Fire Brigade (LFB). Find more.
Act now to request Barnet Overview and Scrutiny Committee to remove site 28 from Barnet’s Draft Local Plan! Email the committee using the link below. Every voice counts!
Together, we can put a stop to this unsound allocation and secure the future of our community.
Best regards, The Save Our Edgware Team
(*Note: One of the roles of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee is to “Review of Issues of Concern to Local People by considering any matter affecting the area or its inhabitants and monitoring and scrutinising the activities of others”)
Alternative way to send the email manually
If the email doesn’t open automatically after clicking the above red button, you can send your email manually by copy and paste the below text manually:
To: Members of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee of Barnet Council
cllr.r.cornelius@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.P.Lemon@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.a.mittra@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.m.shooter@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.d.rich@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.k.mcguirk@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.E.David@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.h.khalick@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.d.thomas@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.j.grocock@barnet.gov.uk,Cllr.D.Cohen@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.p.zinkin@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.a.prager@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.E.Whysall@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.g.innocenti@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.E.Ambe@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.E.Rose@barnet.gov.uk,Andrew.Charlwood@barnet.gov.uk,Fiona.Rae@barnet.gov.uk
CC:
- Barry Rawlings – Leader of the Baret Council
- Ross Houston – Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Homes & Regeneration
- Daniel Thomas – Leader of the Opposition
- Members of the Barnet Strategic Planning Committee
- Councillors at Edgware ward
cllr.b.rawlings@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.r.houston@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.d.thomas@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.p.cohen@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.R.Barnes@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.c.farrier@barnet.gov.uk,Cllr.V.Duschinsky@Barnet.gov.uk,cllr.S.Gordon@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.N.Young@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.R.Chakraborty@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.T.Vourou@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.e.simberg@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.M.Mire@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.L.Wakeley@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.n.mearing-smith@barnet.gov.uk,saveouredgware@gmail.com
Subject: Request Barnet Overview and Scrutiny Committee to Remove Site 28 from Barnet’s Draft Local Plan
Dear Members of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee,
[Please delete this line and please feel free to amend the text to reflect your own concerns or sentiments. Please make sure you include your name and full address at the end.]
I am writing to you regarding Barnet’s Draft Local Plan, which will be discussed at the Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting on 30 January 2025.
I respectfully urge the committee to move an amendment to remove Site 28 (Edgware Underground and Bus Station) from the Local Plan and update all related policies accordingly.
**Why Site 28 Must Be Removed**
The Draft Local Plan allocates 2,316 homes to Site 28, a location that encompasses:
- Operational transport infrastructure, including one of London’s busiest bus stations and garages.
- A protected nature reserve and watercourse.
- A live underground station and operational tracks.
Designating this 8.17-hectare site as suitable for high-density housing is unprecedented and inappropriate. Allocating housing to such a constrained and operationally critical site raises serious practical and safety concerns.
**Concerns Raised by Key Stakeholders**
The London Fire Brigade (LFB) has strongly criticised this proposal:
- In 2023, the LFB deemed the underground bus garage plan beneath 25 tower blocks “not viable.”
- In 2024, they warned of significant fire risks, including structural collapse and toxic vapour explosions from the proposed electric bus garage accommodating 200 buses.
These alarming safety issues have been widely reported by reputable outlets, including the BBC, The Daily Telegraph, and the International Fire and Safety Journal.
**Lack of Proper Scrutiny**
To date, there has been no meaningful scrutiny of:
- The Regulation 18 Site Selection Background Report (2019), which proposed Site 28.
- The Planning Inspectors’ rationale for deeming Site 28 suitable, despite its obvious constraints.
This is the first opportunity for councillors to scrutinise Site 28, and it is imperative that you give our objections and evidence full consideration.
**My Request**
I request that you move an amendment to remove Site 28 from the Local Plan, as defined in MM 109 (pages 484–488 of the latest Local Plan version). Doing so will reflect sound judgment and adherence to the principles of safety, feasibility, and community welfare.
I kindly ask you to inform me of your decision and provide an opportunity for us to engage further if needed.
Sincerely,
[insert your name here]
[insert your address here]
