Act Now: Tell Councillors to Reject the Broadwalk Redevelopment until a safe, deliverable transport plan is guaranteed

On Wednesday, July 23rd, Barnet’s Strategic Planning Committee will vote on the Broadwalk redevelopment (24/2686/OUT). This massive proposal includes 3,828 units in 25 towers, some as tall as 29 storeys. It would demolish Edgware’s existing bus station, bus garage, and car park with no guaranteed replacement.

The plan hinges on an underground electric bus garage that the London Fire Brigade has already flagged as a serious safety risk, citing a lack of existing regulations or precedents.  Transport for London’s (TfL) proposed “diesel fallback” is not a viable alternative; it’s uncosted and lacks any engineering plan. These alarming issues have been widely reported by prominent outlets such as the International Fire and Safety Journal, Fire Protection Association,  The Daily Telegraph, The Sun, BBC and the Evening Standard.

If approved, Edgware risks losing its essential transport infrastructure permanently.

Why Your Action Matters:

The councillors making this decision need to hear from you and understand the overwhelming community concern. This is a critical moment in our campaign.

📢 Act Now! (Thanks to nearly 2000 people who have emailed councillors before the deadline. )

Click the button below to email Planning Committee Councillors and urge them to OBJECT to or defer this scheme.

(Please feel free to amend the text to reflect your own concerns or sentiments. Please make sure you include your name and full address at the end.)

Send Objection Email

This works best on mobile. If the button doesn’t work, see further instructions below.

----

Alternative way to send the email manually

If the email doesn’t open automatically after clicking the above red button, you can send your email by copying and pasting the below text manually: 

To: Members of the Strategic Planning Committee of Barnet Council

cllr.N.Young@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.c.farrier@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.h.khalick@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.j.mastin-lee@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.J.Conway@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.p.cohen@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.R.Barnes@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.r.cornelius@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.S.Gordon@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.t.roberts@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.k.gurung@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.k.mcguirk@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.M.Mire@barnet.gov.uk,cllr.T.Vourou@barnet.gov.uk,Cllr.V.Duschinsky@Barnet.gov.uk

Subject: Request to defer or reject Broadwalk Redevelopment (24/2686/OUT) until safe, deliverable transport infrastructure can be guaranteed

Dear Member of the Strategic Planning Committee,

[Please delete this line and please feel free to amend the text to reflect your own concerns or sentiments. Please make sure you include your name and full address at the end.]

Ahead of the Strategic Planning Committee meeting on Wednesday 23 July, I am writing to respectfully urge you to reject or defer planning application 24/2686/OUT unless fundamental issues – particularly around transport safety, infrastructure deliverability, and accessibility – are fully resolved.

While the intention to invest in Edgware is welcome in principle, the current scheme begins by removing the very infrastructure that keeps the town functioning: the bus garage, bus station, and car park. In its place, it proposes 3,828 units across 25 towers, reaching up to 29 storeys, creating one of the densest developments in the UK, with 137,974 people per sq km. This is 23 times more than Edgware’s norm without securing the requisite infrastructure.

 Key Concerns:

  • Undeliverable Underground Electric Bus Garage
    The London Fire Brigade has raised serious safety concerns, and there are currently no building or fire safety regulations in place to support this kind of infrastructure. Transport for London has not presented a deliverable technical or design pathway.
  • Interim Diesel Garage Is Not a Genuine Alternative
    Diesel buses are being phased out, and the risks related to access and fire remain equivalent. No serious feasibility study has been undertaken. Even if it were technically viable, it would be a temporary stopgap, not a long-term solution.
  • Loss of Core Transport Infrastructure
    The permanent bus station would be replaced with undefined roadside stops, significantly disadvantaging elderly and disabled users, who would face longer walks and have to cross Station Road to reach public transport and be more exposed to the elements.
  • Severe Accessibility and Parking Reductions
    Over 70% of parking spaces would be lost. New Blue Badge bays are proposed to be placed up to 400 metres from key services – well outside accessibility norms.
  • High-Density Housing Without Infrastructure Certainty
    It would be deeply concerning to approve over 3,500 homes in towers up to 29 storeys based on an assumption that essential infrastructure will somehow be delivered later – when evidence strongly suggests otherwise. Once locked in, the consequences cannot be undone.
  • Retail and Economic Risk
    The scheme reduces A1 retail space by 48%, which may severely weaken Edgware’s economy and jeopardise the viability of our local high street especially with the proposed loss of the vast majority of public parking.
  • No Guarantee of Affordable Housing
    With no clear costing for decontamination or infrastructure provision, viability is already under strain – placing future affordable housing delivery in real doubt.

This is not about opposing change. It is about ensuring any development is safe, realistic, and genuinely beneficial to the community it will reshape. I appreciate the difficult position councillors are in, but approving this scheme in its current form would carry serious and irreversible risks.

Please ensure that full and honest answers are provided about transport deliverability, that costed contingency plans are available, and the broader implications for Edgware’s infrastructure, economy, and accessibility are properly understood.

With thanks for your time and public service,

Yours sincerely,

[Insert Your Name]

[Insert Your Address]