Method 2: Comment on Barnet Planning Portal

How to object

To be valid, objections must include at least one “material planning consideration.” You can use the sample objection comment provided, but personalising your objections will make them more impactful.  You can also include one or more of these additional objections. 

Please can you mention that any objections raised by Save Our Edgware and Edgware Community Association should be treated as your own. 

Use this link to Barnet Council’s Planning Portal to comment of up to 2000 characters on the Ballymore TfL’s Edgware development plan.  If your comment exceed 2000 characters, please submit another online comment, beginning the comment with ‘Continued’. 

[Please describe in your OWN words  with your own reasons for objecting and/or express the sentiments in this paragraph. 

Start with “As a resident of Edgware / Barnet / Harrow / Hertfordshire, or a shopper at Broadwalk or commuter from Edgware Station, I strongly oppose …”]

Sample Objection Comment:

Any objections raised by Save Our Edgware should be treated as my own.

I strongly oppose this planning application, as it would severely reduce essential community amenities. Replacing our enclosed, heated bus station—offering 68 seats and a refreshment kiosk—with open-air bus stops is unacceptable, especially for the elderly, disabled, and pregnant women with buggies.

Moving bus operations to public roads will also cause severe traffic congestion on Station Road, further inconveniencing us all.

The Broadwalk Shopping Centre is a vital social hub for our community. It’s covered, warm, provides employment, and is a thriving anchor for Edgware. Its demolition will destroy Edgware as a shopping destination, stripping away a key part of our community life.

Additionally, the proposed 70%+ reduction in parking, from 1,235 spaces to just 292 will make it incredibly difficult for residents, shoppers, commuters, and employees to access local shops and services, further damaging our town’s viability.

The proposed development’s height, bulk, and massing are inappropriate for Edgware, a mid-sized suburban town. This contradicts the National Planning Policy Framework (Section 11b), which discourages new buildings at densities significantly out of character with the existing area.

Moreover, the proposed future underground electric bus garage has been deemed unsafe by the London Fire Brigade, raising serious safety concerns.

This planning application must be reconsidered to ensure that Edgware continues to thrive as a vibrant town centre. Edgware deserves thoughtful development—one that enhances, rather than diminishes, the quality of life for its residents.

Additional Objections:

  • Overwhelming Bulk, Height, and Massing of 25 Tower Blocks Out of Character with Edgware’s Suburban Landscape :

The 25 tower blocks, up to 29 storeys, would dramatically change the character of our area. The ultra-high-density development would cast shadows over homes, block out natural light and make us feel overlooked and less private. The proposed development’s height, bulk, and massing are inappropriate for Edgware, a mid-sized suburban town. This contradicts the National Planning Policy Framework (Section 11b), which discourages new buildings at densities significantly out of character with the existing area.

  • Loss of Light and Privacy

The development of tall buildings of up to 29 storeys will result in significant loss of light and privacy for neighbouring residential areas.

  • Loss of Covered Bus Station

Demolishing the 68-seater covered bus station and relocating stops to Station Road will cause severe congestion, contradicting Barnet Council’s policy for integrated transport services. The reduction of a covered bus station will negatively impact passengers, especially the elderly and disabled.

  • Traffic Congestion

Removing the present off-road bus waiting and boarding facilities will inevitably require this operational facility to be moved on to public roads (Station Road to be specific) which will cause severe congestion, contradicting Barnet Council’s policy for integrated transport services.

  • Loss of Shopping Mall

The Broadwalk Shopping Centre serves as a social hub: it’s covered, warm, provides employment, and is a thriving anchor for the community. Its demolition will destroy Edgware as a shopping centre. The closure of the Broadwalk shops for several years will severely negatively impact local businesses.

  • A staggering 70%+ cut to public parking spaces

A 70%+ cut in public parking spaces will reduce parking bays in Edgware from 1,235 to 292, severely impacting shoppers, commuters, and local workers. It will hit the elderly, disabled, and parents with young children particularly hard. Local businesses will suffer as customers are driven away by the lack of parking.

  • Blighting of local businesses

The Broadwalk, apart from Sainsbury’s, will be demolished in the first year of the development.  Replacement shops will appear in the fifth year. 

The Broadwalk is a local destination for people living in neighbouring towns and suburbs as well as people living in Edgware.  The absence of shops like TK Maxx, Boots, WHSmith, JD Sports and Choice for four to five years will encourage people to shop in other towns or suburbs.  

When the shops eventually return there will be insufficient parking, and people will be in the habit of shopping elsewhere.  The case for retail chains setting up in Edgware will be far less persuasive than at present.

With fewer big-name shops as a pull and less parking, it is questionable as to how many shops in Station Road will survive.

  • Overburdened Healthcare Services

Local doctors’ surgeries are at capacity. The influx of 10,000 new residents will overwhelm existing healthcare facilities. Merely providing a space for healthcare is insufficient as the deficiency is funding for additional healthcare facilities so the developers should also be required to fund the ongoing healthcare of the incoming new residents.

  • Education Shortage

The plan does not address the need for new schools, worsening the existing shortage of school places.

  • Future underground EV bus garage, a fire safety risk 

The proposed underground electric bus-charging garage poses significant fire risks, particularly under thousands of new homes. Whilst this has been recognised by the developers, they have failed to seek a solution. They propose to continue with their plan to dig a basement which they hope can one day actually be used as a bus garage, but until technology provides their hoped-for solution, they merely propose that the bus fleet will be stabled on the former Broadwalk car park and that the electric buses will be charged in the open air by contamination-spewing diesel generators.  So much for TfL’s stated intention that the sole reason for joining in with this redevelopment proposal is to change the bus fleet over to electric power in order to reduce contamination in Central Edgware.

  • Impact on Historic Buildings and Conservation Areas

The proposed towers will overshadow Grade II Listed buildings like the Railway Hotel and St Margaret’s Church, violating national planning policies. The bulk and height of the buildings will detract from nearby Conservation Areas, such as Edgware High Street, Canons Park Estate, and Watling Estate.

  • 12 years of construction disruption until 2037

The extended period of demolition and construction will significantly increase noise levels and air pollution, impacting local residents.

  • Threat to Wildlife and Biodiversity in Deansbrook Nature Reserve

The Deansbrook Nature Reserve has been protected from public access and hence left to nature for almost 100 years. It is a now a precious rare habitat and is one of the most important (if not THE most important) habitats in the Borough and so has been designated a Site of Importance to Nature Conservation. Building a paved bicycle slalom-run on it will simply encourage children and young adults to play noisily on it, not to mention other unsavoury activities that might be encouraged by the semi-seclusion of the woodland. Merely throwing in a few bat boxes (which might anyway become a target) is simply not good enough to safeguard the endangered legally protected species such as bats and slow-worms, violating environmental regulations. This area should continue to be safeguarded from public access to protect biodiversity.

  • Insufficient Public Transport Capacity

The Edgware Transport SPD Section 7 wrongly assumes existing bus capacity is adequate for new development. With plans to reduce car parking spaces, immediate increases in bus capacity are essential, given the projected 50% population increase in Edgware.

  • Concerns Over Outline Application

While this is an Outline Application, it appears the developers are using it to gain in-principle consent for a significant overdevelopment, avoiding key issues. Planning consent should not be granted until they provide satisfactory details to Barnet Highways and others, including:

  • The replacement for the demolished bus station.
  • Operation plans for bus services during construction without causing gridlock.
  • Interim bus garaging and charging solutions, given the London Fire Brigade’s refusal to approve the proposed underground bus garage.
  • Health Risks from Overcrowding

High-density living conditions increase disease transmission risks and strain local healthcare services.

  • Safety and Crime Concerns

The plan fails to ensure a safe environment, with high-rise buildings posing risks for children and reducing community oversight especially to vulnerable families who will have no choice other than to accept the high-rise social housing flats they are offered. High-rise estates are associated with increased crime and antisocial behaviour, contradicting local policies.

  • Water and Drainage Issues

The site includes flood-prone areas, posing safety risks with the proposed development.

  • Lack of Green Space

The development fails to meet environmental standards, lacking sufficient green space. This diminishes the quality of life for future residents and does not comply with London Plan requirements.