Legal Challenge Launched Over Barnet’s “Potentially Unlawful” Plan to Build on Vital Transport Infrastructure in Edgware

Edgware, UK, 31 March 2025 – Save Our Edgware, a grassroots community group, has launched a legal challenge against Barnet Council’s decision to allocate Site 28—land currently used for Edgware’s bus station, bus garage, Underground station, and part of the Deans Brook Nature Reserve—for high-rise residential development.

The group, represented by public law specialists Leigh Day, has issued a formal Pre-Action Protocol letter, warning that Barnet’s newly adopted Local Plan is unlawful, irrational, and based on flawed consultation and planning assumptions that ignore the real-world constraints of the site.
 
What’s at Stake
 
Site 28 covers 8.17 hectares of land in the heart of Edgware Town Centre — a site that is not vacant or underused, but instead home to critical TfL infrastructure. It includes:
  • The bus station and bus garage, serving thousands of daily commuters
  • The Underground station and track network
  • The Deans Brook Nature Reserve, a designated Site of Borough Importance for Nature Conservation
Despite the site’s operational and environmental sensitivity, Barnet has allocated it for a dense residential-led redevelopment, including 2,316 units on Site 28 — part of a wider scheme proposing 3,828 units and 25 high-rise towers in partnership with Ballymore and Transport for London.
 
“You can’t just draw a line around a functioning transport hub and call it housing land,” said Anuta Zack, spokesperson for Save Our Edgware.
 
“This plan assumes essential infrastructure can be relocated or built over — but there’s no evidence it can be done safely or at all.”
 
Fire Brigade Raises Alarm on Planning Application Feasibility
 
Concerns about Site 28’s viability are already being borne out. In response to Ballymore’s 2024 planning application — which includes an underground electric bus garage beneath residential towers — the London Fire Brigade warned that the structural integrity of the buildings above could be at risk in the event of a fire.
 
While these concerns relate to the planning application and not the Local Plan directly, Save Our Edgware argues they highlight the lack of realism and due diligence behind Site 28’s inclusion in the Local Plan. The Council has not explained how housing of this scale can be safely delivered while maintaining uninterrupted bus and Underground services.
 
Residents Left Out of the Process
 
The group also claims that Barnet failed to carry out a lawful consultation, particularly during the pandemic, when in-person events were suspended. Many local residents — including those living just metres from the site — were unaware of the Local Plan’s proposals until Ballymore submitted its initial scoping planning application in 2023.
 
Since then, public opposition has grown rapidly:
  • Over 6,000 people have signed a petition
  • More than 2,300 residents have joined the Save Our Edgware Facebook group
  • 300+ formal objections were submitted during the 2024 Main Modifications consultation of the Local Plan
What the Group Is Demanding
 
Save Our Edgware is calling on Barnet Council to:
  • Withdraw Site 28 from the Local Plan immediately
  • Pause all progress related to the site pending legal review
  • Disclose feasibility evidence, including communications with TfL and assessments related to infrastructure constraints
If the Council does not respond by 7 April, the group may be forced to initiate a High Court challenge.
 
“We’re not opposed to regeneration — we’re opposed to fantasy planning,” Zack added. “Ignoring fire risks, biodiversity, and transport constraints just to meet housing targets is bad planning and bad governance. Edgware deserves better.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *